Meet Brian and Charlene — Your Hosts at Hillcrest Retreat

The Story Behind Hillcrest

Some people find their place in the world early. Others take the long way around.

Brian Mahaffey took the long way around — and it made all the difference.

Born and raised in the upper Ohio Valley, Brian spent ten years living in England as a dual American and British citizen. He learned what genuine hospitality looks like from a culture that has been perfecting it for centuries. He learned to brew real ale in the British tradition — malty, complex, made with patience and craft in the way that cannot be rushed or faked. He learned what a proper pub feels like — not just a bar but a gathering place, a living room, a space where people become real with each other over a proper pint.

When Brian came home to Chester, West Virginia he brought all of it with him.

The real ale brewing happens in the original 1890s farmhouse — the same building that has stood on this land since C.A. Smith's era. The pub room with its carved mahogany bar and cast iron pot belly stove is the living expression of everything Brian learned about hospitality during a decade in England. The imperial pint glasses. The proper pour. The welcome that waits at the bar when guests arrive.

England taught Brian what hospitality could be. West Virginia gave him the home to practice it in.

Charlene — The Heart of Hillcrest

If Brian is the history and the ale — Charlene is the warmth that makes Hillcrest Retreat feel like home from the moment guests arrive.

Charlene is a Registered Nurse. She has spent her career taking care of people — anticipating needs before they are expressed, noticing details that matter, responding with calm competence when things go sideways. Those are not just nursing skills. They are the exact skills that generate 4.99 stars across over 100 Airbnb reviews.

The welcome wine on the counter when you check in — that is Charlene. The snack basket stocked with the things guests actually want — that is Charlene. The robes in the bathroom. The extra blanket folded at the end of the bed. The note that tells you where everything is without making you feel like you need a manual.

The barn doors she installed in the farmhouse living room. The sage green walls. The way every room at Hillcrest feels considered and intentional without feeling designed or staged — that is Charlene's eye and Charlene's hands.

Brian brews the ale. Charlene creates the home. Together they have built something that guests return to year after year.

Why They Host

People ask Brian and Charlene why they open their historic estate to guests rather than keeping it private.

The honest answer is that a place this extraordinary has an obligation to be experienced.

A genuine 1890s pub that has gathered people for over 130 years. A farmhouse built on land that was once the most famous cattle farm in America. Two thousand acres of West Virginia wilderness at the door. The Ohio River ten minutes away. The hills and fields and orchard rows of Hancock County stretching in every direction.

This is not a place that should sit empty on the weekends while Pittsburgh couples drive past on their way to generic Airbnb rentals in generic mountain towns.

Brian and Charlene host because they believe the right guests — the ones who appreciate history and wilderness and genuine hospitality and a proper pint of handcrafted ale — deserve to experience what they get to live every day.

The England Connection

Ten years in England left a permanent mark on how Brian thinks about hospitality.

The British pub tradition is one of the great social institutions in human history. Not because of the alcohol but because of what the space creates — a neutral ground where people from every walk of life sit together, share a proper drink, and become human with each other for a few hours.

Brian brought that tradition back to a genuine 1890s West Virginia farmhouse pub and made it his own. The real ale he brews uses traditional British methods. The 20 ounce imperial pint glasses. The bar setup that reflects decades of learning what makes a pub feel right.

When guests walk into the Hillcrest pub they feel something they cannot quite name. They feel that a real person with real knowledge and real care put this space together. They feel that the ale in their glass was made by someone who understands what ale should be.

That feeling comes from ten years in England and a lifetime of genuine hospitality.

A Note From Brian and Charlene

We live on this property. We are always close by if you need us. We are always respectful of your privacy if you do not.

We will never make you feel like a customer. You are a guest in our home — on our land — in a building that has sheltered people through over a century of Ohio Valley history.

Brian will tell you where to find the deer at first light and which corner of the WMA the pheasants favor in November. He will talk ale with anyone who wants to talk ale. He will tell you the story of C.A. Smith and what this land was. He knows these hills and this river and this community in the way that only someone who grew up here and came home here can know them.

Charlene will make sure everything is exactly right before you arrive. She will think of the things you did not know you needed. She will respond to any message with the calm competence of someone who has spent a career making sure people are well taken care of.

We are proud of Hillcrest Retreat. We are proud of what we have built here together. And we are genuinely honored every time someone chooses to spend their time here with us.

Welcome to Hillcrest.

— Brian and Charlene Mahaffey

[Book The Hillcrest Manor Cottage] [Reserve The Skyview Cabin] [Experience The Historic Pub] [Contact Us